http://www.idolreview.net/2010/01/27/lalala-and-a-cat-fight-to-boot/ American Idol reviews and news Thu, 02 Feb 2012 04:15:01 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.2.1 http://www.idolreview.net/2010/01/27/lalala-and-a-cat-fight-to-boot/comment-page-1/#comment-18425 Alan C Pursell Tue, 09 Feb 2010 18:36:59 +0000 http://www.idolreview.net/?p=903#comment-18425 To The American Idol Producers: I love the show and I love to see unknowns make their dreams come true. But, the show has always had some serious flaws. Simon is a music producer, not a musician. I don’t know how he ever got on the show, but I’m glad to see him go. But, replacing him with a Buffoon like Howard Stern would only kill the show. The other judges aren’t much better. That Beckham woman was especially sad, More concerned with what the contestants were wearing than how they sang. With Simon leaving, you have a great opportunity to make the show much more of a singing competition, as it should be. Only a few times have I ever heard any of the judges mention pitch or range. A true judge will always consider these aspects of a contestant’s ability along with… Tone, vibrato control, enunciation, breath control, inflection, rhythm and posture. We don’t have to take away to entertainment aspect of each contestant, But let’s throw in a few technicals to make it a true singing competition. Looking forward to your improvements. Alan. To The American Idol Producers:
I love the show and I love to see unknowns make their dreams come true.
But, the show has always had some serious flaws.
Simon is a music producer, not a musician.
I don’t know how he ever got on the show,
but I’m glad to see him go.
But, replacing him with a Buffoon like Howard Stern
would only kill the show.
The other judges aren’t much better.
That Beckham woman was especially sad,
More concerned with what the contestants
were wearing than how they sang.
With Simon leaving, you have a great opportunity to make the show much more of a singing competition, as it should be.
Only a few times have I ever heard any of the judges
mention pitch or range.
A true judge will always consider these aspects of a contestant’s ability along with…
Tone, vibrato control, enunciation, breath control, inflection, rhythm and posture.
We don’t have to take away to entertainment aspect of each contestant,
But let’s throw in a few technicals to make it a true singing competition.
Looking forward to your improvements.
Alan.

]]>