Comments on: Lights, Camera, Action! (Top 7) http://www.idolreview.net/2009/04/14/lights-camera-action-top-7/ American Idol reviews and news Thu, 02 Feb 2012 04:15:01 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.2.1 By: Gretchen Daul http://www.idolreview.net/2009/04/14/lights-camera-action-top-7/comment-page-1/#comment-6809 Gretchen Daul Sat, 18 Apr 2009 01:34:26 +0000 http://www.idolreview.net/?p=750#comment-6809 Regarding Kara's comment on Kris's song, "You picked an obscure song," does she know it won the Academy Award? How obscure is that? Regarding Kara’s comment on Kris’s song, “You picked an obscure song,” does she know it won the Academy Award? How obscure is that?

]]> By: Laura http://www.idolreview.net/2009/04/14/lights-camera-action-top-7/comment-page-1/#comment-6649 Laura Wed, 15 Apr 2009 16:58:52 +0000 http://www.idolreview.net/?p=750#comment-6649 Yeah, he would be great singing Paradise City. Yeah, he would be great singing Paradise City.

]]> By: Megg http://www.idolreview.net/2009/04/14/lights-camera-action-top-7/comment-page-1/#comment-6638 Megg Wed, 15 Apr 2009 13:30:24 +0000 http://www.idolreview.net/?p=750#comment-6638 Anyone else feel like Adam is the new Axl Rose? I feel like he NEEDS to sing "Paradise City." Go listen to it..and tell me that's not Adam singing it. (And I'm not on the Adam ban-wagon so that's saying a lot!) Anyhoo--I see Lil, Danny and Matt in the bottom 3. Lil is going home and the judges won't even entertain the thought of saving her. Anyone else feel like Adam is the new Axl Rose? I feel like he NEEDS to sing “Paradise City.” Go listen to it..and tell me that’s not Adam singing it. (And I’m not on the Adam ban-wagon so that’s saying a lot!)

Anyhoo–I see Lil, Danny and Matt in the bottom 3. Lil is going home and the judges won’t even entertain the thought of saving her.

]]> By: Miljan http://www.idolreview.net/2009/04/14/lights-camera-action-top-7/comment-page-1/#comment-6618 Miljan Wed, 15 Apr 2009 09:45:36 +0000 http://www.idolreview.net/?p=750#comment-6618 Oh yeah - another thing - the way Ryan kept pronouncing and shortening "Quentin" was horrible. The first time he pronounced it was eeeeks. And the last time it just sounded like "Quit Tarantino". Argh. Oh yeah – another thing – the way Ryan kept pronouncing and shortening “Quentin” was horrible. The first time he pronounced it was eeeeks. And the last time it just sounded like “Quit Tarantino”. Argh.

]]> By: Miljan http://www.idolreview.net/2009/04/14/lights-camera-action-top-7/comment-page-1/#comment-6617 Miljan Wed, 15 Apr 2009 09:43:42 +0000 http://www.idolreview.net/?p=750#comment-6617 My goodness... yeah, the biggest movie songs ARE ballads, but could they have chosen more boring stuff? Again, Adam was in his own league. And I agree with the comment above - he's not exciting to be heard in a studio recording, but live on stage. And though all his performances are done by the same recipe - sing a bit the normal tune, go higher, step it up higer, go for the high note, go down, slide up and down and hit the high note at the end again and maybe slide a bit more - it's always exciting. Matt, Kris, Allison, Danny, all boring. Good vocals, but overall boring. Anoop was great. And Lil was great too. And there's the thing I don't get with the judges. It kinda gets more and more obvious that they're kinda biased towards some of the contestants. Even the ever-speaking-only-his-mind Simon. First, as well as him, I didn't get what Paula wanted to say to Lil. Paula does that a lot and it starts annoying me. And then Simon critisizes Lil for doing what he asked previously Danny to do? I mean - the girl sings great, she did a great job with the changing up the song (though I don't know why the judges insist that much on "changing up the songs"), she did everything they said she (and other people) should do and they still criticize her? And way to go for her to talk back. You could really see she too was frustrated because they're so contradictive. Anyhow, for tomorrow, I can see Matt, Alison and Kris in the btm 3. And why the heck would they invite another Screechy to the show? Miley Cyrus? Come on! :rolleyes: My goodness… yeah, the biggest movie songs ARE ballads, but could they have chosen more boring stuff?
Again, Adam was in his own league. And I agree with the comment above – he’s not exciting to be heard in a studio recording, but live on stage. And though all his performances are done by the same recipe – sing a bit the normal tune, go higher, step it up higer, go for the high note, go down, slide up and down and hit the high note at the end again and maybe slide a bit more – it’s always exciting.
Matt, Kris, Allison, Danny, all boring. Good vocals, but overall boring.
Anoop was great.
And Lil was great too.
And there’s the thing I don’t get with the judges. It kinda gets more and more obvious that they’re kinda biased towards some of the contestants. Even the ever-speaking-only-his-mind Simon. First, as well as him, I didn’t get what Paula wanted to say to Lil. Paula does that a lot and it starts annoying me.
And then Simon critisizes Lil for doing what he asked previously Danny to do? I mean – the girl sings great, she did a great job with the changing up the song (though I don’t know why the judges insist that much on “changing up the songs”), she did everything they said she (and other people) should do and they still criticize her? And way to go for her to talk back. You could really see she too was frustrated because they’re so contradictive.
Anyhow, for tomorrow, I can see Matt, Alison and Kris in the btm 3.
And why the heck would they invite another Screechy to the show? Miley Cyrus? Come on! :rolleyes:

]]> By: ryanflip http://www.idolreview.net/2009/04/14/lights-camera-action-top-7/comment-page-1/#comment-6611 ryanflip Wed, 15 Apr 2009 07:04:25 +0000 http://www.idolreview.net/?p=750#comment-6611 i pretty much agree with everything you commented on this one, tho, i think Matt was a little bit worse than you think he was. Otherwise, spot on. i pretty much agree with everything you commented on this one, tho, i think Matt was a little bit worse than you think he was. Otherwise, spot on.

]]>