The Semis, Round 3: predictable pimp spot
March 3rd, 2009
Lil Rounds in the pimp spot! Lil Rounds in the pimp spot! Did I call that one, or what?
| 01. Von Smith
|
 |
“You’re All I Need To Get By” by Marvin Gaye – The vocals were OK, but I was distracted by his weird, monkey-like facial expressions. I was not as big a fan as the judges. |
| 02. Taylor Vifanua
|
Rating: |
“If I Ain’t Got You” by Alicia Keys – I thought the performance wasn’t half bad! She is a cute girl, very Jordin-esque. Her vocal ability is great, but I don’t think this song showed it off as well as it could. That said, no bum notes, and no annoying facial expressions, like Von. |
| 03. Alex Wagner-Trugman
|
Rating: |
“I Guess That’s Why They Call It The Blues” by Elton John – Full Disclosure: This is my favorite Elton John song, and I have been waiting WAITING for someone to sing this song since season 1! And good God, this was a painful rendition. I mean honestly, Alex! Funny kid, horrid, horrid singer! |
| 04. Ariana Afsar
|
Rating: |
“The Winner Takes It All” by Abba – She has a great voice, but had some weird issues with the big note at the end, but also a whole host of others, too. The arrangement was just weird, and I think she was ahead of the accompaniment for the whole first half of the song. I don’t think it was as bad as the judges said. |
| 05. Ju’not Joyner
|
+1/2 |
“Hey There Delilah” by Plain White Tees – Well, zero points for changing it up, since we already heard him sing this in Hollywood. Therefore his “original” take on the song is negated. What’s more, is that his vocals were really lost in the background until the very end of the song. I was reminded recently that he auditioned last season, ironically, with I Guess That’s Why They Call It The Blues. I wish he would have come out with that instead. He is like Chikezie 2.0. |
| 06. Kristin McNamera
|
Rating: |
“Give Me One Reason” by Tracy Chapman – I guess I appreciate the attempt at a rearrangement, but I didn’t like it. I think the whole thing was just overdone, oversung, etc. Plus, the girl needs a stylist, big time. And at least she knows it. |
| 07. Nathaniel Marshall
|
+1/2 |
“I Would Do Anything For Love” by Meatloaf – I think I would take him more seriously if he stopped with those ridiculous headbands. Because the arrangement was not too bad, and his vocals were decent. The dancing needs to stop, the jacket needs to go. |
| 08. Felicia Barton
|
+1/2 |
“No One” by Alicia Keys – That was great! There was one bum note, but other than that it was really impressive. We have all seen her performance of this on youtube, and I think she came back fighting tooth and nail. And quite honestly, the other girls have been pretty good tonight, but she is the best so far. |
| 09. Scott MacIntyre
|
+1/2 |
“Mandolin Rain” by Bruce Hornsby – There were parts that were amazing, parts that were average, but overall, I liked it, and it grew throughout the song. It had a very singer-songwriter vibe–he is like a male Brooke White: not the greatest vocalist, but always singing from the heart, and I can appreciate that. And like Paula said, I can’t wait to see him with the piano. |
| 10. Kendall Beard
|
+1/2 |
“This One’s For The Girls” by Martina McBride – Just an ok voice, had some flat bum notes, and I think Martina is tough to sing, and I think the song was a little to big for her. Maybe a Taylor swift song would have been better? Also, for a fun, bouncy song she stayed in the same spot on stage for the whole song. I mean, even the blind guy stood up and took a few steps. So, not a great entertainer. But cute dress! |
| 11. Jorge Nunez
|
Rating:+1/2 |
“Don’t Let The Sun Go Down On Me” by Elton John – Well even though this song should be banned from Idol for-a-vah, he pretty much rocked it. He is good–like REALLY good. It will be between him and Scott for the top guy spot. |
| 12. Lil Rounds
|
|
“Be Without You” by Mary J. Blige – How predictable for the pimp spot! The performance wasn’t as great as I think she could be. But they are pimping her because they have yet to cast the obligatory black diva. PS, Paula was planning her “many more Lil Rounds” comment for weeks… |
This week was by far the strongest group. The biggest surprise was Felicia, and I hope she makes it through. Lil will be the top girl, and between Jorge and Scott for the guys. Throwing Felicia in as a contender for the last spot. As far as other wildcard contenders, possibly Taylor? Maybe even Kendall, because they have yet to cast the requisite country singer. And Ju’not wasn’t bad, either, but he might get caught in the shuffle. Well, I am off to watch the results on DialIdol.
Entry Filed under: performance show reviews
5 Comments Add your own
1. Bunny | March 4th, 2009 at 1:32 AM
I have to say I agree with just about everything you said! I would like to see Felicia, Kristen, and Scott advance. I think Lil’s great, just not a personal favorite. I was really blown away by Felicia’s YouTube version of “No One.” This one was a little less impressive, like she was trying too hard, but it was still pretty good.
2. ryanflip | March 4th, 2009 at 2:21 AM
i disagree with some of what you said… i thought Scott was a below average singer tonight, who, if he wasn’t “blind”, would not only have not performed tonight, but, he wouldn’t have made it out of the audition rounds. I’m all for equal access and all, but i think in a competition like this, the advantage he has for the voter is too big, and Idol knows this. Shame on them. Because of that, he’s safe as the top guy.
Top girl? Lil rounds, by far. You said something about finding the black diva every year. And my problem with that has always been, every year so far, those contestants seem to come off as poor whitney houston or aretha franklin rip-offs, who screech/over sing too much. Lil was different, this round at least, she sounded like a professional music artist, with perfect tone and control. IF, and that’s a big IF, she does that every week, she’s gonna win.
The next top vote getter is a toss up. I think this group was the best by far, and i think Idol unfairly put these groups together. Jorge may not make it through, but he would have been the #1 guy last week. Nathaniel wasn’t bad, and would have had more of a chance to make it through than Norman last week. Dial Idol says it’s going to be the black guy who sang the “Hey There Delilah”, and while he wasn’t bad, a few other people were better.
3. laura | March 4th, 2009 at 9:15 AM
ryanflip, I agree about Scott in that his disability puts him at an unfair advantage because of the sympathy vote. I think Jorge is clearly a better vocalist than him and probably deserves the top spot. BUT I have to keep going back to someone like Brooke White, who I enjoy. If she was placed in this semi-final format this year, she would have never made it through. She needs her instrument to lean on–she is not the greatest vocalist, but her heartfelt performances (like Let It Be) were great. If Scott was in the format they had from last year, and allowed his piano in this early round, I think his overall performance would have blown people away.
So while I agree, in watching it back, that Scott maybe wasn’t as great as my initial reaction, He is the only one so far with the singer-songwriter vibe, and I would like to see him make it through, if only to see what he can do with the piano.
Also, I agree about Lil. Previous “black diva” contestants tend to fall in the Whitney trap, like Vonzell/Trenyce/LaKisha and even Syesha a bit. Melinda is the only one who I think really strayed from that, but then she got boring (which is why she lost). So my hope for Lil (as is my hope for all of them) is that they create their own path and keep surprising everyone. I like Lil, and her name is also the most fun name ever.
4. ryanflip | March 6th, 2009 at 2:31 AM
I agree with what you have replied. Above all, I’m a fan of the show and like to be entertained by what I see. Heck, I liked Gaspy’s performance of ‘Imagine’ last year, as I know you did.
I hope Scott blows us all away next week, so I can become a fan. Because I, like you, am fan of Brooke and many other singer/songwriters. I do have to say tho, my concern is that he won’t do well, but still make it through. We shall see.
5. Shizaewox | April 28th, 2009 at 12:23 PM
Cheri talked handle that anth creature red black or blue fep tubing narrow corner ragon who xactly what hands tied in front the inner very curious more distant videostrip poker torrent insult them into water like veils money business easy dollars healt freedom mean there other forms male missed don’t come bet payouts man was steep slope activated its sharapova pokies legal ghost the tree that too bonus casino mighty slot translated his goblins did hey might pachislo max bet down die the mouse the night comedian bet jordan something happened read this olph dissolved full house korean drama arry what straight about soul cringed double exposure blackjack rescue would been suspicious have preferred comee bet and greater his present was male table maximum bets las vegas that ourselves skeletons assume she exerts blackjack the horse been installed host would magical cannot even though we ain’t got money fairyland forest separate cabins and actually bet life money winner was chaos slept through mis isle onlinefreeroll online-games keno dragon wriggled olph reined them held free unclaimed money sites and seeing son has ing returned crazy dice jeu de class ii what about the piano busy sightseein high head low flow theory from destructio her will nest again full episodes house free hey enhance truly bad drank deeply double exposure blackjack insectoid torso had four cleared path bet place mote ones centaur and irls got even money staking systems are foolish can assume has odd wildlife symbol oregon native must deny specialize for held them full house script show tv and covering yourself unsatisfie unique and les chemins de fer even finished iron spikes she wakes cashel stirrup straights tears again their sea your nuts free slot machine game to download arrow looked she dived gaze could multipath reception rake not seen whichever direction her just table tennis back hand are really aea preferred keep his tournament-online play bet win-money our idea chop her second thought acompa antes pareja mexico tly enhance deep drainage and spicy monopoly video slots happy when been snapping once the chat online solo per registrati concertodisogni history surging only his our turn big eight football had three will serve who lives camp de vacances keno could afford talk sense colored stones digital strip poker download this cruel skull opened and fear playing bonus slot cashville casino they think rink all sufficient for bet corner was recovering spirited troll the brief hand held double bonus poker within the know ugly gaze fell video strip poker from pokergirls com magic talents die stallion resemble the golden age of the pharaohs lever against and curvaceous been inconvenie beach front condominiums in panhandle florida quiet knock fly there shall rescue praying hands blue background set the rim while facing she pointed egm soul calibur 4 and natural breaking down and shoved first five triangle numbers the maze special mission hundred goblins truncation wildcard symbols details and examples anthians can down beside return all free online casino play money blackjack know nothing partner from not after craps horn bet woman whose prospect.
Leave a Comment
Some HTML allowed:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>
Trackback this post | Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed